Camille Saint-Saëns
born 9 Oct. 1835 in Paris
died 16 Dec. 1921 in Algir
Composition::
1858 in Paris
1879 published by Durand & Fils, Paris
1880, 13 February: first performance in Paris, soloist: Martin-Pierre Marsick
CD recordings:
Ivry Gitlis, violin 1968
Philippe Graffin, violin 1998
Fanny Clamagirand, violin 2009
Jolente De Maeyer, 2013
Camille Saint-Saëns does not need to be promoted in our context. He made more famous contributions to the virtuoso violin concerto literature than almost any other Romantic composer of the
19th century. His Havanaise in E major, op. 83, his Introduction et Rondo capriccioso, op. 28, and also his Danse macabre are famous. But his three violin concertos are less well known; the third
violin concerto in B minor, op. 61, is the one most likely to be played in today's concerts. Here I would like to make a plea for the chronologically first violin concerto in C major by the
early, gifted, young, romantic Saint-Saëns, which is almost forgotten in concert halls.
It is also known that Saint-Saëns, composer and organist, led an extremely long life. He was 86 years old, lived through many phases of French music history and at the end of his life had to
realise: "What else do I want? To be the future and not the past? I have been the future; in my early days I was considered a revolutionary - at my present age, you can only be an
ancestor."
It is less well known that Saint-Saëns was a child prodigy: at the age of three, he wrote his first piano piece by himself - "without having been whipped at the piano", as he later confessed;
at the age of 10, he made his debut as a pianist; at 15, he completed his first symphony; at 17, he became an organist, first at the Église Saint-Merry in Paris and later at the Église de la
Madeleine.
The Violin Concerto No. 2 in C major also dates from Saint-Saëns' youth. He composed it in 1858 at the age of 23, after he had already performed symphonies and many other works with
considerable success. Although chronologically his first violin concerto, it is not a modest first compositional work, but a musical departure on a self-confident journey through life with
virtuoso demands. Saint-Saëns wrote it for the painter and violinist Achille Dien, with whom he played chamber music in his youth. With the aspirations of youth, he wanted to overcome rigid forms
and lead the musical events into the expanse of romantic longing for new beginnings, albeit still freely orientated towards classical patterns. Saint-Saëns seems to have been familiar with
Vieuxtemps' violin concertos, but also with Mendelssohn's violin concerto, whose opening with the solo entry of the main theme over preceding accompanying figures before the orchestral
introduction became a model for him.
Saint-Saëns later published his Violin Concerto C major in 1879 as his second violin concerto with Durand & Fils, Paris. It was officially premiered in 1880 by the Belgian violinist
Pierre Martin Marsick (later violin professor at the Paris Conservatoire and teacher of Carl Flesch, Jacques Thibaud, Cécile Chaminade and George Enescu).
Saint-Saëns once said: "The solo in a concerto must be designed and treated like a dramatic role". In this violin concerto in C major - one could say - the young Saint-Saëns musically assumes
the role of a young and free Romantic artist of the 19th century.
Listen to it here!
Listening companion:
NB: The following listening guide owes some of its observations and formulations to these contributions:
Duncan Druce: CD accompanying text to the hyperion recording with Philippe Graffin;
Albert Beaujean: Art. Saint-Saens, Concerto for Violin and Orchestra No. 2 in C major, in: Lexikon Orchestermusik Romantik edited by Wulf Konold.
The violin's expansive solo theme rises maestoso above moving C major quavers in the low strings. This energetic and virtuosic main theme immediately establishes the solo violin as the Romantic
protagonist. The theme is soon given a contrasting, rather lyrical continuation. Only then does the orchestra take over the main theme in its own colourful way in a longer tutti passage and adds
two secondary ideas to it, first a lyrically swaying secondary idea and then a majestically soaring, memorable orchestral motif.
When the solo violin enters again in the most beautiful woodwind light, the music changes to E major. As it turns out, this theme is based on the lyrical continuation of the main theme and
spreads out longingly on the G string of the solo violin. What now happens in the development-like middle section is completely free play with all the themes and motifs, which are repeatedly
strung together in new and contrasting ways and pass us by. The memorable orchestral motif, which once again comes to the fore, stands out magnificently. The free passage of the themes forms the
background for the free development and presentation of violinistic and musical possibilities.
After a build-up of the main theme in the orchestra, the recapitulation begins. The violin responds with the now lyrically varied orchestral motif from the side ideas of the orchestra's
exposition. A cadenza prepared by the orchestra, written by Saint-Saëns himself for this concerto, allows the solo violin to once again display all of its musical possibilities and
themes before the orchestra and solo violin lead to the conclusion of the movement, where the memorable orchestral motif once again appears majestically.
In dark A minor, the low strings intonate a three-part motif twice, which the solo violin immediately transforms into a sad song with harp sounds. The dark motif reappears, emphasised by serious
trombone sounds, but the violin continues to sing its song full of melancholy and sadness and expands its melody. The orchestra slowly joins in. The plaintive song continues in the flutes.
Then, in a descending figure, the violin breaks out into a violent, resigned lament, the orchestra also escalates into a violent outburst in C major, an act of indignation? The solo violin
answers recitatively, a high flute joins in and low winds form a threatening background. A comforting flute melody precedes the solo violin and leads them back to an increasingly calming
song.
However, an eerie and long, expressive build-up in the orchestra drives the violin to an agitated solo outburst; once again, the solo violin seeks solace in its renewed song, accompanied by
sympathetic woodwinds. However, the dark mood reappears in the reprise of the opening motif in the brass, and the violin responds once again with its extended silent song in a low register
accompanied by the sound of the harp. An impressive movement, hinting at the romantic depths and abysses, comes to an abrupt end... without an end, as the end of this movement is led directly
into the cheerfulness of a final rondo by a lively transition.
Should there be a genuine joie de vivre? Or does the finale depict the pseudo-cheerfulness of the philistine bourgeoisie, or does the music flee into the depiction of romantic irony? We have no
time to think about it, we are immediately swept into the thick of the action by the violin. This also makes this last movement somewhat ambivalent. The movement begins with a lively,
rhythmically elegant all-round theme, the violinist strides forward with a long line, the orchestra follows and asserts itself noisily.
After the orchestral tutti, the violin takes the lead again and plays a colourful couplet. The orchestra supports the music with rhythmically driving interjections. When the round dance threatens
to tire, the violin finally emits sharp cries over the pizzicati of the strings (as if "the hen from Le Carnaval des Animaux has made an untimely appearance", as a careful listener will
hear).
The all-round theme starts again in the violin and orchestra, followed by another couplet where the violin can once again showcase its virtuoso runs. The orchestra dialogues with the violin
colourfully and at the height of the orchestration of the time. Towards the end, the young Saint-Saëns demonstrates his counterpoint skills in a brilliantly whirling fugato, before the
movement concludes with a triumphant stretta.