Mieczysław Karłowicz
born 11 Dec. 1876 in Wiszniewo
died 8 Feb. 1909 in the mountains of the High Tatras
First performance:
21 Mar. 1903 by Stanislaw Barcewicz and with the Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra, conductor: M. Karłowicz
Recordings:
Tasmin Little 2003
Nigel Kennedy 2006
Julia Fischer, J. 2023 (on Youtube)
At the age of 32, the avid mountain walker and skier Mieczysław Karłowicz was buried by an avalanche in the High Tatras and died. His compositional output is therefore small, some early
works, then the Violin Concerto and finally eight symphonic poems, which he composed back in Poland's city of Zakopane inspired by the mountains of the High Tatras. He joined the group of "Young
Poles" together with the musicians Grzegorz Fitelberg, Ludomir Różycki and Karol Szymanowski, but was considered a loner who liked to retreat to the mountains. The eight symphonic poems are
influenced by the world of Symbolism and Neo-Romanticism and bear witness to a sound style all their own, which knows how to tell orchestrally of human existence and infinity. Although these
works are still performed in Poland today, they are virtually unknown outside of Poland.
At the age of 26, Mieczysław Karłowicz composed his Violin Concerto in Warsaw. However, it was written for Berlin, where it was premiered by Karłowicz's violin professor and violin virtuoso
Stanisław Barcewicz and the Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra and then repeated in Vienna. From the surviving music reviews of these premieres:
""The 'Violin Concerto' is also a very beautiful work, especially in the second movement, where it approaches the style of a Bach violin cantilena. And the orchestral accompaniment is so
subtle and fresh, in contrast to the banal accompaniments of Sarasate, Vieuxtemps, etc."
"Karłowicz loves lively and rich orchestration, which may sometimes seem too dense to us, but everything he writes sounds beautiful. His themes may not be entirely original, but they have a
special inventiveness".
Karłowicz had the best prerequisites to position himself in the European world of music at that time. As the son of an important scholar, he travelled through Europe with his family as a
child and resided alternately in Heidelberg, Dresden, Prague and Warsaw. He was encouraged in many ways, learned to play the violin professionally, but then decided to compose. The models for his
early works were Tchaikovsky, Wagner and Richard Strauss. Even in the Violin Concerto, Karłowicz quotes the beginning of Tchaikovsky's B-flat minor Piano Concerto, albeit in the inversion of the
tonal sequence. As a trained violinist, he knew the violin literature of his time. Enlightening for the understanding of his violin concerto is the following self-positioning on the violin music
of his time:
"Violin music can be divided into two categories: some works invite a demonstration of the musician's technique, bristling with difficulty but poor in content; others place the content in the
foreground, without regard to the nature and special characteristics of the instrument. The former are written by violin virtuosos who are not always endowed with creative talents and have
insufficient knowledge of the music; the latter are the work of talented composers who want to write for the violin but do not know enough about the nature of the instrument. Only a few works
fall in the middle."
Among these violin concertos in the middle is the Violin Concerto by Mieczysław Karłowicz. Compositionally, it is structured in terms of motifs. And indeed, the numerous multiphonics and
figurations of the violin part with its very high tempi and trills are demanding. It takes a technically very accomplished violinist to master these difficulties.
Listen here!
Listening companion:
Two horns and a bassoon set the beginning with a festive signal and awaken the attention. This opening motif will recur in the course of the movement. On closer listening, it turns out to be the
same sequence of notes as the famous opening of Tchaikovsky's B-flat minor Piano Concerto, an ommage from Karłowicz to Tchaikovsky.
But then the violin starts off solo and plays the rhythmically interesting and energetically charged main theme with virtuoso double stops, which is followed by the signal motif in the orchestra
in a gentle variation. The violin takes the lead and leads virtuously to the solemn repetition of the rhythmic main theme. The theme slowly fades away in the descending movement of the strings
and in concluding soft woodwind chords.
The violin enters again with an airy violin transition, accompanied motivically by the high woodwinds.
This flash of serene atmosphere prepares the vocal second theme, which also reveals itself influenced by the initial signal motif. The solo violin sings its romantically broad melody,
counterpointed by the bassoon and underscored by the sound of the horns.
Abruptly, a certain restlessness and brief uncertainty enter the musical action, and the development begins. At first, the violin takes refuge in wild figurations emanating from the rhythmic main
thena. The orchestra stops the violin with a kind of fanfare, darkens the mood and gives the violin the opportunity to go into itself recitatively on the dark G side. Slowly, the solo violin
regains air from the heights and movement in time, supported again and again by the orchestra in a cooperative motivic manner. Finally, the orchestra prepares festively for the onset of the
cadenza.
During the cadenza, the main theme changes into virtuoso playfulness. At the end, the main theme appears in a spherical sound world of the woodwinds. This time the violin takes over the
accompaniment and prepares the solemn, life-affirming reprise of the main theme in the full orchestra.
Again, the violin's airy impressionistic interlude relieves the main theme and leads on to the second romantic singing theme. This singing is abruptly interrupted again, but the cheerful sounds
soon dominate and a festive coda ends this life-affirming Allegro moderato.
A horn melody attacca connects the first movement with the romance that now follows. Quietly and gently, the orchestra introduces the violin With a love melody that takes up and continues the
romantic character of the secondary theme of the first movement, the violin "spreads its soul wide, as if it were flying home" (Eichendorff). A bassoon, a horn, an oboe and the solo flute float
along.
Overwhelmed by so much emotion, the violin shakes itself as if waking briefly from a dream in the middle section of the Romance. The passionately accompanying orchestra supports and protects it
until the violin, thanks to the assistance of a horn that takes over the love melody, finds its peace again in gentle dreamlike accompanying figures. Even more enchanting and dreamlike, the
violin begins to sing its love melody, and the orchestra accompanies it even more spherically until the final fade.
In a Vivace assai, trumpets, followed by the full orchestra, pull us out of our dreams. The violin is also on the spot and plays a 6/8ths dance.
Only a while later does the violin almost languidly recall what it experienced in the Romanza, but it immediately launches back into the relaxed and somewhat self-indulgent dance pleasure.
After this almost scherzo-like rondo section, the orchestra stops the rush and introduces a contemplative lyrical melody which the violin immediately takes over in double stops. Serious interjections by the orchestra drive the violin into wild excitement until it finds its way back to its dance-like rondo theme. The pleasure continues, a lust for life accelerates the violin's virtuosity, and everything pushes towards a life-affirming final hymn, which once again recalls and takes up the main theme of the first movement in festive sound. A final relaxed gesture by the violin and conclusion.